Technically savvy bitcoiners have been using multivendor multisig hardware wallet setups for years. Now, following the Coldcard crisis this summer and the problems affecting Ledger and its users this month, the approach is gaining the attention of the wider audience. It combines hardware from different manufacturers in a multisignature wallet setup.
For example, in a 2-of-3 setup, three keys are created on three different devices, and two of them are needed to sign a transaction. If one device is compromised, criminals hold only one key and still cannot steal your bitcoin, though you should still replace that key. This would have protected users in both the Coldcard and Ledger cases, as long as the other devices came from other manufacturers and, as the Ledger case shows, through different sales channels.
Compromising all the devices in order to move bitcoin from a multisig wallet would require a highly coordinated attack. For example, an attacker might target three devices bought from the same reseller, which could have tampered with the wallets itself or fallen victim to a supply chain attack. Compromised Ledger reseller Cryptobilis also sold Trezor, Tangem, Safepal and other devices. So far, only Ledger devices have been confirmed as tampered with. That is why the safest practice is considered to be buying hardware wallets directly from the manufacturer. However, while this reduces the risks, it does not eliminate them.
‘Should Become the Standard’
“Rolling dice wouldn’t have helped the victims of the Ledger supply chain attacks. Multivendor multisig would, again,” Kevin Loaec, CEO of Wizardsardine, the developer of the Bitcoin wallet Liana, posted on X.
“Multi-vendor multisig should become the standard. Each signer should have a completely independent hardware/software stack from the other signers,” developers of the Nunchuk wallet added, noting that “any setup that relies on a single hardware/software stack or a single vendor should be considered at risk.”
Both Liana and Nunchuk are developing their own multisig solutions to help users combine different devices. However, these solutions do not yet support all the hardware wallets available on the market.
Payers and Gainers
If multivendor multisig does become the standard, single-device users could face additional expenses, but the investment could pay off in the long term. For example, Ledger wallets currently retail for $59-399, Trezor wallets for $59-249, and BitBox devices for $167-196. Another option is Block’s Bitkey device, which costs $250 and offers a multisig solution without seed phrases.
Bitkey distributes three keys among its hardware wallet, the user’s mobile device, and a Bitkey server. While this is safer than a single-signature setup, users still need to trust that the solution from a single vendor works as intended.
If people rush to create multivendor multisig setups, hardware wallet manufacturers could see a direct boost in sales. Bitcoin.com News has already reported that some manufacturers saw a spike in sales following the Coldcard crisis. The trend could also change competition among manufacturers, as users would no longer look for a single “best hardware wallet.”
Other potential beneficiaries include multisig solution providers such as Liana and Nunchuk. Companies such as Casa and Unchained, which offer collaborative multisig solutions, could also see their user bases grow. They could even become more important sales channels for hardware wallet manufacturers. Casa does not specify which wallets it offers to subscribers of its Premium and Private Client plans, which cost $2,100-7,500 per year. Ledger previously said they “worked closely with Unchained to validate and improve our approach to multisig, in an open-source collaboration.”
Fear of Multisig vs. Fear of Losing Your Bitcoin
However, following the Coldcard crisis, Ledger CTO Charles Guillemet warned that “Multisig is not automatically the right answer” because it adds complexity, increasing the risk of losing funds. Guillemet advocated for a miniscript solution instead, which would allow users to set simple rules for how their bitcoin can be spent, including through multisig transactions. At the time of writing, Guillemet had not posted anything about the Cryptobilis incident.
Multivendor multisig might therefore seem even more complex to most bitcoin and crypto users. How popular the trend becomes will depend on multiple factors. A key factor will be whether repeated attacks heighten users’ fear of losing bitcoin enough to force those who still want to self-custody their BTC to learn how to set up multivendor multisig wallets.
Another question is how the Bitcoin and broader crypto asset industries will help these users with better, more user-friendly, and less risky solutions. Alternatively, users could turn increasingly to custodial solutions or investment vehicles such as ETFs.
Ultimately, as the adage goes, there is no single best bitcoin custody solution or hardware wallet.
When it comes to choosing between different options, there are always trade-offs to consider. The right choice ultimately depends on your individual needs and technical abilities. Whether you’re deciding between software solutions, hardware devices, or any other technology, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons to make an informed decision.
One recent example of this principle in action is the discovery of hidden hardware implants in European Ledger wallets. These devices, designed to store cryptocurrency securely, were found to have been tampered with in a way that compromised their security. This revelation has raised concerns about the safety of using such wallets and has prompted users to reevaluate their options.
New social media reports suggest that these compromised Ledger wallets may not be limited to Asia, indicating that similar tampered devices may be circulating in other regions as well. This development underscores the importance of being vigilant and informed when it comes to choosing technology solutions, especially in the ever-evolving landscape of cybersecurity.
In light of this discovery, users are faced with a choice: stick with their current Ledger wallets and take extra precautions to mitigate the risk of exploitation, or switch to a different wallet provider that may offer a higher level of security. Each option comes with its own set of trade-offs, and the right choice will depend on the individual user’s needs and technical capabilities.
For users who are comfortable with technology and willing to invest the time and effort into securing their devices, sticking with their current Ledger wallet may be a viable option. By following best practices for cybersecurity and staying informed about potential risks, they can continue to use their wallets with a reduced level of vulnerability.
On the other hand, users who prioritize convenience and peace of mind may opt to switch to a different wallet provider that offers enhanced security features. While this may involve a learning curve and potentially additional costs, it could provide a higher level of protection against potential threats.
Ultimately, the decision of whether to stick with a compromised Ledger wallet or switch to a different provider is a personal one that each user will need to make based on their own priorities and circumstances. By carefully weighing the trade-offs and considering their own needs and technical abilities, users can make an informed choice that aligns with their values and goals.
