MSCI recently approved new rules that could jeopardize Strategy’s index membership as its shares are trading nearly 69% below their peak. This decision comes after the global index provider announced on Oct. 15 that it would be adopting a new methodology that excludes companies classified as non-operating businesses from its Global Investable Market Indexes. These changes are set to take effect after the market closes on Nov. 30, with the final list of affected companies being released on Nov. 11.
Strategy, a Bitcoin treasury company led by Michael Saylor, is at risk of losing access to billions of dollars in index-linked investments. The company has seen one of its deepest declines in stock value since it shifted to Bitcoin as its primary treasury asset in 2020.
MSCI had already identified Strategy, along with Japan’s Metaplanet and uranium investment company Yellow Cake, for potential deletion in an August simulation using May financial data. Ethereum treasury company SharpLink was also placed on a proposed watchlist.
The new methodology implemented by MSCI will first assess whether a company has substantial operating assets. Companies that fail this initial screen will then face five financial ratio tests, with failure on at least four making them ineligible for index inclusion. Existing constituents must fail the eligibility screen in both of their two most recent annual filing periods before removal. MSCI may also consider the most recent interim filing.
This framework replaces previous restrictions targeting companies whose digital assets represented at least 50% of their total assets. MSCI had initially considered outright exclusion before expanding its review to businesses whose activities resembled investment vehicles.
For Strategy, this decision poses a significant threat that the company has been actively challenging. In September, Strategy argued that excluding Bitcoin treasury businesses would undermine MSCI’s neutrality and create an arbitrary distinction between operating companies and investment vehicles.
Market commentator Mark Harvey shared a chart based on Yahoo Finance daily closing prices, showing that MSTR is currently 68.7% below its peak value. Despite the significant decline, Harvey sees this as a generational buying opportunity, reflecting optimism about the company’s long-term Bitcoin exposure outweighing its current challenges.
JPMorgan analysts estimated that MSCI’s removal could trigger approximately $2.8 billion in passive selling of MSTR shares.
There is a divide among market observers on how MSCI-related selling would impact Strategy, given the stock’s substantial trading volume. Bitcoin analyst Adrian Morris argued that concerns of a destabilizing selloff overlook the liquidity available in MSTR shares. According to Morris, Strategy generated around $565.25 billion in dollar trading volume this year, with an average daily trading volume of $2.91 billion.
In a similar vein, Strategy’s ability to finance future Bitcoin purchases could face challenges if sustained selling pressures reduce the premium at which MSTR trades relative to the value of its Bitcoin holdings. This could impact the company’s strategy of aggressive accumulation through common stock issuance at favorable premiums.
In its latest disclosure, Strategy reported acquiring 250 BTC for $21.5 million, primarily funded through selling common shares. The company also spent $192.4 million repurchasing STRC preferred stock during the same period.
As MSCI prepares to publish the final constituent changes on Nov. 11, the potential removal of Strategy from the index could lead to significant changes in index-tracking funds as they rebalance for implementation by the Nov. 30 close.
