The recent ruling by the Sixth Circuit on September 25 has significant implications for Kalshi’s sports contracts in Ohio and Tennessee. The court’s decision allows both states to enforce their gambling laws on Kalshi’s sports contracts, despite the company’s argument that it conflicts with its obligations as a federally regulated exchange.
The court rejected Kalshi’s claim that compliance with state laws would interfere with its duties under federal regulations, citing geofencing as a viable solution to satisfy both state and federal requirements. This ruling is a blow to Eilers & Krejcik Gaming, as most of Kalshi’s retail sports demand comes from states without legal online sportsbooks.
The court found that Kalshi’s sports contracts do not meet the definition of a swap under the Commodity Exchange Act, which would have granted exclusive oversight by the CFTC. Even if the contracts were classified as swaps, the court ruled that federal commodities law would not preempt state gambling statutes in Ohio and Tennessee.
The decision gives states within the Sixth Circuit two paths to enforce their laws on Kalshi’s sports contracts. The court affirmed an Ohio ruling against Kalshi, vacated a preliminary injunction in Tennessee, and sent both cases back to lower courts.
Kalshi argued that compliance with Ohio and Tennessee laws would be impossible due to its obligations as a designated contract market. However, the court interpreted federal requirements as allowing for geographic restrictions and pointed to companies using geofencing to comply with both federal and state laws.
The ruling has implications for Kalshi’s sports demand, with 69% of its retail sports demand coming from states without legal online sportsbooks. California and Texas account for 44% of this demand. The decision also affects the competition between prediction markets and licensed sportsbooks in different states.
The court’s decision comes at a crucial stage in the legal battle and sets a precedent for federal courts in Ohio, Tennessee, Michigan, and Kentucky. The split among circuit courts on Kalshi’s preemption argument could impact the future of sports contracts nationwide.
Overall, the Sixth Circuit’s ruling has significant implications for Kalshi’s operations and the future of prediction markets in the United States. The decision highlights the challenges faced by companies operating in the intersection of federal and state regulations and sets the stage for further legal battles in the industry.
