Four Republican senators who voted to advance the CLARITY Act on Sept. 15 are now named supporters on a bank-backed amendment seeking tougher restrictions on stablecoin yield. John Cornyn, John Curtis, Cindy Hyde-Smith, and Lisa Murkowski all voted in favor of the procedural motion, which unfortunately fell short 49-50. These senators also signed onto Sen. Jerry Moran’s stablecoin amendment, which the banking industry has been advocating for as a fix to the language in the bill.
The math behind the CLARITY Act’s 11-vote gap is crucial to understanding the current situation. The cloture vote on Sept. 15 required 60 votes to pass but only received 49, with one senator not voting. Losing any of the four senators supporting the amendment would widen the gap even further. Moran’s amendment aims to replace the current standard for prohibited stablecoin rewards with broader language that covers anything substantially similar to how depository institutions pay interest or yield.
The banking industry is concerned that certain stablecoin rewards could function economically like deposit interest under this broader definition, potentially leading to community banks losing deposits to such products. The existing draft of CLARITY includes a regulatory circuit breaker that allows regulators to intervene if harm to community banks is found within 18 months of enactment. However, banking groups argue that this approach reacts too late and defeats the purpose of the restriction.
The negotiations surrounding CLARITY involve two separate issues: stablecoin yield language favored by bank-aligned Republicans and ethics provisions addressing public officials’ financial interests in cryptocurrency pushed by Democrats. Winning over both groups is essential for the bill’s success. The coalition of senators supporting the bill is crucial, with the possibility of some senators withholding their support until the stablecoin language is revised to their satisfaction.
The future of CLARITY hinges on these negotiations and the support of key senators. The Moran amendment represents a potential stumbling block that could impact the bill’s chances of reaching the 60-vote threshold. The Senate is expected to continue deliberations on CLARITY in the coming weeks, with the outcome uncertain until a new vote is scheduled. The success of CLARITY will depend on the ability of negotiators to address the concerns of both bank-aligned Republicans and Democrats while maintaining the support of the existing coalition of senators.
