A recent study has shed light on the differences between Solana (SOL) swap prices for traders and returns for passive pool depositors. The study, conducted from Sept. 1, 2025, through Aug. 31, 2026, compared propAMMs controlled by professional operators to public automated market makers (AMMs).
PropAMMs had a reference-relative execution cost proxy of 0.26 basis points for quiet-market SOL/USDC fills, while public AMMs had a much higher proxy of 2.59 basis points. This difference in execution costs can impact the swap price for traders and the returns for pool depositors.
The study also looked at two-second gross maker markouts, which showed that propAMMs had a positive markout of +0.37 basis points, while public AMMs had a negative markout of -0.22 basis points. These markouts compare a fill with a later reference price and can influence the profitability of the pool.
When an outside market moves first, a pool offering stale prices can result in trades being executed too cheaply or dearly. This can lead to arbitrage opportunities, but the correction comes through trades against the existing liquidity in the pool.
The study also highlighted the importance of analyzing LP economics, including asset exposure, fees earned, inventory changes, hedging, operating expenses, and transaction costs. These factors can impact the overall profitability of passive pool depositors.
Overall, the study emphasized the need for a comprehensive assessment of returns for passive liquidity providers and the benefits of liquidity pools managed by professional operators. By actively managing pricing risk, these pools can attract traders looking for better swap prices.
In conclusion, the study pointed out the importance of quote reliability and the need for better routing mechanisms to ensure fair execution for traders and optimal returns for passive pool depositors. By addressing these issues, the Solana ecosystem can create a more efficient and profitable trading environment for all participants.
