EU finance ministers have made a significant decision to transfer oversight of major crypto companies to a central watchdog, marking a shift in supervision under the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA). This move comes as part of a broader effort to integrate European financial markets and enhance regulatory oversight in the crypto sector.
The Council of the European Union recently reached a political agreement to give the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) direct responsibility for overseeing the most significant crypto-asset service providers in the EU. This decision aims to address a key weakness in MiCA, which allows firms licensed in one member state to operate across the entire 27-country bloc while primarily being supervised by their home-country regulator.
However, the agreement is narrower in scope than the European Commission’s initial proposal, which sought to place all crypto service providers under ESMA’s supervision. Estimates suggest that only around 10 to 15 out of approximately 360 providers would qualify for centralized oversight under the new agreement.
While the agreement sets the Council’s negotiating position, it does not immediately change the law. The Council will need to engage in negotiations with the European Parliament to finalize the proposal.
The current MiCA framework includes a passporting system that allows crypto firms to enter the European market through a single authorization in one member state. While this system reduces administrative burdens for firms expanding across borders, it places significant responsibility on the national authority that issues the initial approval. This can lead to challenges when a company’s operations and client base extend beyond the jurisdiction where it was licensed.
A recent review by ESMA highlighted issues with the authorization process of a crypto provider by the Malta Financial Services Authority, questioning the approval process and identifying gaps in governance, technology infrastructure, and anti-money laundering measures. This case underscored the need for enhanced supervision at the EU level to ensure consistent regulatory oversight across all member states.
In response to these challenges, EU regulators are proposing a new framework that would see ESMA directly supervise crypto providers with a large user base or meeting specific criteria related to assets under custody, transaction volumes, and financial interconnectedness. This approach aims to ensure that supervision is based on a provider’s overall scale and impact on the financial system, rather than its place of incorporation.
Under the proposed framework, ESMA would have the authority to request information from supervised firms, conduct inspections, investigate breaches, and impose financial penalties. The agency would also work with national regulators to address enforcement disparities and ensure consistent regulatory practices across jurisdictions.
The transition to the new supervisory model would involve a two-year period during which operational responsibilities and expertise would be transferred to ESMA. Existing MiCA licenses for companies brought under direct supervision would remain valid, minimizing disruptions to business operations.
Overall, the proposed changes aim to enhance oversight of a select group of large crypto firms while maintaining the current national regulatory model for the majority of the market. The final thresholds, ESMA’s resources, and the treatment of providers near the boundary will be key considerations in the negotiation process between the Council and the European Parliament.
Once the negotiating positions are formalized, discussions will determine the extent of the transfer of supervision from national regulators to the EU level and establish a timeline for implementation. This shift towards centralized oversight represents a significant step towards harmonizing regulation in the rapidly evolving crypto sector.
