The US Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) made a significant announcement on October 5 regarding the withdrawal of a reporting proposal for crypto mixing. Crypto mixing involves using techniques to obscure a transaction’s source, destination, or amount, and the proposed plan would have required financial institutions to report information about covered transactions and their customers.
The proposal went beyond dedicated mixing services and applied to all financial institutions, regardless of the protocol or service used. Examples of activities that would trigger the reporting obligation included pooling funds, coordinating transactions with code, splitting transfers, routing funds through a series of single-use wallets, exchanging between crypto assets, and introducing user-initiated delays.
However, FinCEN decided to withdraw both the 2023 finding that international crypto mixing is a class of transactions of primary money laundering concern and the proposed recordkeeping and reporting rule. The withdrawal notice was scheduled to be published in the Federal Register on October 6, and the withdrawal took effect upon publication.
One of the main reasons for the withdrawal was concerns raised by commenters that the expansive definition of crypto mixing could stifle legitimate activity and impose a significant reporting burden on financial institutions. The proposed definition also excluded certain internal processes used to execute transactions at banks, broker-dealers, and money services businesses, as long as they retained source and destination records and provided them when legally required.
Despite the withdrawal of the reporting proposal, compliance checks for covered crypto money transmitters still remain in place. These entities are subject to registration, risk-based anti-money-laundering programs, applicable customer checks, recordkeeping, and suspicious activity reporting. Additionally, qualifying transfers are still subject to the Funds Travel Rule.
It’s important to note that FinCEN’s existing guidance distinguishes between an anonymizing service that accepts and retransmits value and a supplier of anonymizing software. Providing a tool alone does not classify someone as a money transmitter, but operating a transmission business does. Furthermore, an unhosted-wallet user who pays for goods or services on their own behalf is not considered a money transmitter based on that activity.
In addition to the withdrawal of the crypto mixing reporting proposal, FinCEN also addressed the separate unhosted-wallet proposal that was published in December 2020. This proposal was already listed as withdrawn on April 12, 2024, in the Spring 2024 regulatory agenda, and FinCEN stated that they will take no further action on it.
FinCEN emphasized that they will continue to monitor crypto mixing for money laundering, terrorist financing, and other illicit activities and may take further steps in the future. Financial institutions are reminded that their existing obligations remain relevant when assessing privacy-related transactions in the crypto space.
