The US Securities and Exchange Commission’s recent proposal for crypto custody fallbacks has the potential to expand investment opportunities and simplify the process for larger advisers to offer these services. The agency’s economic analysis highlights the challenges faced by smaller firms in safeguarding assets and providing independent oversight, which may deter them from providing crypto custody services.
Approved on October 1st, the proposal allows advisers to hold client crypto assets when an eligible custodian is unavailable, subject to certain safeguards. The estimated annual cost per adviser using this option is around $433,833, which includes expenses for an independent control report but excludes additional technology costs that may be significant.
The proposal distinguishes between adviser “self-custody” and investors holding their own assets. In the self-custody model, an intermediary would hold clients’ key materials, potentially including a non-controlling portion, with clients relying on the intermediary’s safeguards.
For ordinary advisory clients, the amendments pertain to crypto assets that are funds or securities, while regulated-fund accounts focus on securities or similar investments.
The largest component of the estimated annual cost is the independent internal control report, with an average cost of $376,000, along with $57,833 for recurring internal compliance work. These costs are based on 300 initial hours and 100 recurring annual hours at $578.33 per hour, covering information, communications, and agreements between adviser and client.
The proposal also outlines the process for determining when the fallback option can be used, requiring advisers to have a written reasonable basis that no qualified custodian is available for each asset before taking custody. Advisers must reassess this quarterly and transfer assets to a qualified custodian as soon as one becomes available.
The safeguards included in the proposal aim to mitigate risks associated with holding client assets, such as misuse, misappropriation, and operational errors. These safeguards include asset-specific expertise, cybersecurity protections, annual reviews, reporting, and client disclosures.
Alternative custodians, such as state trust companies and national and state banks, are also permitted under the proposal, offering clients additional options for custody services. The cost advantage of using these alternative custodians will depend on the specific asset and custody arrangement.
Overall, the SEC’s proposal aims to provide a framework for advisers to offer crypto custody services while ensuring the protection of client assets. The success of the proposal will depend on the implementation costs, independent accountant pricing, and the availability of eligible custodians to support a wide range of assets.
