New York has taken legal action against Polymarket, accusing the US prediction market of operating as an unlicensed gambling business in the state. Attorney General Letitia James filed a petition on Sept. 24, seeking to halt QCX LLC, which operates as Polymarket US, from offering event contracts without a state gaming license. The petition also requests restitution, disgorgement, and potentially significant penalties for the alleged violations.
Polymarket, which is regulated at the federal level by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a designated contract market since July 2025, is facing a legal challenge over the intersection of federal derivatives oversight and state gambling laws.
The crux of New York’s case against Polymarket lies in the structure of its contracts. Users purchase contracts based on the outcome of future events, with payouts contingent on whether the specified event occurs. The state argues that these transactions constitute gambling under New York law, as customers are risking money on events beyond their control.
Governor Kathy Hochul emphasized this point, stating that simply labeling it as a “prediction market” does not change the fact that it falls under New York’s gambling laws. The state highlighted Polymarket’s marketing efforts, which included promotions for sports contracts and events such as the New York governor’s race and reality TV shows.
In addition to the gambling allegations, New York also raised concerns about age restrictions, as Polymarket allows users aged 18 and above to participate, while the state requires sports bettors to be at least 21. The attorney general argued that unlicensed operators like Polymarket circumvent necessary safeguards and taxes imposed on licensed gaming companies, depriving New York of critical revenue that supports essential services.
The legal action seeks to shut down Polymarket’s sports contracts and prevent the company from operating an unlicensed gambling business in or from New York. New York is also seeking restitution for customers, damages, disgorgement of profits obtained through alleged violations, and penalties equal to three times Polymarket’s gains from the illegal activity.
This lawsuit against Polymarket is part of a broader push by New York to crack down on companies offering event contracts through prediction market structures. Similar actions were taken against Coinbase Financial Markets, Gemini Titan, and Kalshi earlier this year, with the state seeking forfeiture of profits, restitution, and fines equal to three times the companies’ gains from the challenged activities.
The legal dispute between New York and Polymarket underscores the ongoing tension between federal derivatives regulation and state gambling enforcement. As the case unfolds, it will shed light on how prediction markets like Polymarket navigate regulatory frameworks at both the federal and state levels.
