Despite the failure of the CLARITY Act in the Senate, Bitwise Chief Investment Officer Matt Hougan remains optimistic about the current bull market in crypto. He argues that Bitcoin’s recent rally was already in motion even as the bill’s chances of passage dwindled.
The Senate’s rejection of cloture on the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act with a narrow vote of 49 to 50 on Tuesday was a setback, falling short of the 60 votes required to move the legislation forward.
Hougan points to Bitcoin’s performance since July as evidence that the market was not solely reliant on the bill. From July 1 to September 4, Bitcoin surged from $57,950 to over $80,000, while the Polymarket odds of the CLARITY Act passing this year dropped from 39% to 18% during the same period, according to Bitwise.
“If the bull market hinged on Clarity’s approval, we would have seen a decline in prices as the odds dropped,” Hougan noted.
Furthermore, he highlighted that major financial institutions have continued to venture into the crypto space despite the uncertainty surrounding the legislation. Robinhood launched its blockchain in July, Morgan Stanley introduced Ethereum and Solana exchange traded products, and DTCC completed tokenized securities trades.
With the failure of the CLARITY Act, regulatory attention may now shift towards the SEC and CFTC, which have the authority to enforce crypto regulations under their current mandates.
In August, the SEC proposed Regulation Crypto Assets, outlining a framework for specific investment contracts involving digital assets. Following the Senate vote, the SEC approved a temporary Innovation Exemption allowing qualifying platforms to facilitate onchain trading of tokenized US stocks under specific conditions, signaling a proactive approach in the absence of legislative progress.
CFTC Chair Michael Selig has also expressed readiness to implement crypto market structure regulations using existing authority if legislative action stalls.
While agency rulemaking lacks the permanence of legislation, Hougan acknowledged that future administrations could reverse regulatory policies. Congress would still need to grant the CFTC broader jurisdiction over crypto spot markets.
Despite a 4% dip in Bitcoin’s price post the Senate vote, attributed to market factors like interest rates and oil concerns, Hougan views the CLARITY setback as a temporary hurdle rather than a halt to the overall market momentum.
